TLCR

The problem for tradespeople

To earn well, a tradesperson is expected to run a business.

A qualified tradesperson can work alone, contract to a larger firm or take a job. Each has a cost that has little to do with the trade. Our evidence so far is from plumbing and heating, the first trade we have looked at.

Working alone is a second job

A self-employed tradesperson keeps the accounts and files the tax return. They buy the van and the insurance, find the customers, price the work and chase the payment. The trade itself is done in the hours that are left.

  • 95%of UK plumbing and heating firms had fewer than ten employees in March 2025.
  • 5,880of them had no employees at all.

So this is how most of plumbing and heating works. We have not yet counted the other trades. The count leaves out sole traders too small to register for VAT, so the real share is higher.

Contracting to a larger firm keeps most of the burden

Some larger firms take tradespeople on as self-employed contractors. The firm finds the customers and sets the price, and the contractor is paid a share of the labour charge.

The contractor is still a business in law. They do their own tax and insurance and may pay for the van. The hours, the uniform and the rules can look very much like a job, and in some arrangements the contractor goes unpaid if the customer does not pay.

In 2018 the Supreme Court looked at one such contract and held that the plumber was legally a worker, not an independent business.

Terms differ from firm to firm, and we have seen only a few of them.

A job has a different cost

Employment takes the business away. People who have left employers describe what came with it: hours and terms changed without their agreement, limits on private work, and pay below what they could earn alone.

Some of the same people say they miss it. They mention steady earnings, colleagues to ring and time off that is really off.

What we do not know

  • How many tradespeople would choose to be employed if the terms were good.
  • Whether pay or terms matters more to them.
  • How much of a self-employed tradesperson’s week goes on running the business.
  • How common each of the three arrangements is, and how far other trades differ from plumbing and heating.

What we have read is a small number of engineers’ own accounts, a few firms’ recruitment pages and one court judgment. We have not yet interviewed tradespeople ourselves.

Where the figures come from

  • Office for National Statistics, “Plumbing and heating enterprises, 2024 and 2025” (ad hoc release AH1797). UK, March 2025. It counts firms registered for VAT or PAYE in the class “plumbing, heat and air-conditioning installation”, so it includes commercial and air-conditioning firms and leaves out sole traders too small to register.
  • Recruitment pages on London plumbing and heating firms’ websites, read in November 2026, some of them recruiting other trades. These are adverts, not contracts.
  • A Supreme Court judgment of 2018 on the status of a plumber engaged as self-employed ([2018] UKSC 29). The contract in the case dates from 2009.
  • Engineers’ own accounts published online, in videos and on employer-review sites. A small number, and not a survey.

Tell us what went wrong.

A job at your home that went badly. A firm that treated you badly when you worked for it. We are collecting both before we open, and what we hear will shape what we build. It takes two minutes and you do not have to give your name.

Tell us what happened